Skip to main content

Remove Prince Harry from the line of succession?

Well this is a new one.

So, personally, while I have no vested interest here and I'm not a UK Citizen, my vote would be "no". And this isn't just a personal preference thing. I have a few technical reasons and a few on the more personal side. So let's dispense, shall we?

On the technical side, being a "working royal" has never been a factor in succession. In fact, as the monarchy has slimmed down over the years, the number of those with no formal duties who have remained in the line of succession has only increased. The remove the son of the King while many lower in line who aren't working royals still exist would be lunacy.

In fact, his place in line and his relationship the King are also very good reasons NOT to eject him.

While modern monarchies are not under constant threat of assassination, every monarchy needs a line of succession with heirs who have some level of legitimacy. Being directly related to a living monarch is about a strong a claim as one can have. In a monarchy such as the UK has, it is also important for heirs to be relevant. The biggest threat to the monarchy is not assassination or a lack of heirs, but rather the government deciding that they are no longer needed.

So, taking this into account. Who is after Harry? Prince Andrew. Whoops! Do you still want to skip over Harry? If you also eliminate Andrew and his family, then we start delving into even less relevant royals.

None of this is really all that pertinent though. As most have stated; at present, the odds that Harry will ever become King are basically non-existent. Why this does matter is setting precedent for future generations. The only way that the King would remove his son from the line of succession would be through a motion to change how the line of succession is determined in general. Likely, such that it maintains the current limitations and adds that they are recognized as working royals.

But, as birth rates decrease, it becomes increasingly important for future generations to not prune too far.

Especially since, outside of leaving royal duties behind, Harry has not really done anything which should otherwise exempt him. There has been internal squabbling, but that is just social unrest. And if half of what he says turns out to be true, then even the claims that these things he has done are "bad" would be brought into question as well.

Which brings us to the personal side, or the "what-if?" scenarios. To date, Harry seems to be predominantly opposed to racist and other exclusionary behaviors taken inside the monarchy by staff and members of the family. And also with some of the policies which exist to maintain a clean image for the royal family. On the surface, eliminating these things would make the monarchy more approachable and relevant. It also opens them up to risk, which is likely why the policies exist. 

However, beyond the fact that what Harry seems to want to open up the royal family to risk by tearing back some of secrecy and restraint. It otherwise seems like he would want changes that would actually improve the odds of the monarchy remaining relevant and for longer. The biggest risk he brings personally is exploiting the situation for lucrative TV contracts, but that would likely also be a moot point if the monarchy reformed to his liking as he would likely just try to re-enter that lifestyle and live off the ample income which he used to receive for that lifestyle.

In short, a lot of what people dislike about Harry at present are tied to:

  • How he perceives he and his family were treated and
  • What he feels he needs to do to survive
Both of those seem likely to disappear if he ever did inherit the throne, OR, more simply, if the root causes of his frustrations were actually addressed.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Kyudo Blog #2 - Shinsa Prep

So, we're well past my first year. I decided to take the video shinsa for shodan at the end of the year. We also, have a new cohort joining the dojo. Things are getting interesting. This journey has not been at all what I expected. First, I had expected Kyudo to be both more and less introspective. Our dojo focuses more on Taihai, or the ceremonial/performance aspect of the art. And that comes with a lot of concern for harmony and beauty as a group. Making movements up to shai (firing line) in unison as much as possible.  At the same time the focus on the self is infinitely more than I could have anticipated as well. Posture, breathing, form and movements. Everything seems to have a right way of doing it. And none of those "right ways" come naturally. Beyond that there is also etiquette. Even things you might not associate with the practice itself are a part it. And all of these things then also need to be in harmony with everything else. Needless to say, I have a long wa...
Post a Comment
Read more

Kyudo Blog #3 - The basics

Right now my biggest (though certainly not only) issues are the fundamentals. The basics. Posture, speed and form. I know form is a very broad term, but I'm talking about specific forms like my ENSOU, or even TENOUCHI. On the posture front, I'm a software guy. I sit at a desk all day and have developed a bad posture for years. This isn't impossible to overcome. But it is far from trivial. And breaking out of a good posture mid performance can make an otherwise acceptable showing into a bad one. Correcting my posture, similarly, draws attention to its absence prior. On the speed front, this isn't technically a fundamental, but it is an area of focus at the moment. I'm doing video shinsa this year. And apparently I need from my YU at HONZA until my HANARE on my OTOYA to be about 3 minutes. Right now... closer to 4. My pauses between movements tend to be too long. I like to make my pauses pronounced to punctuate the division between one movement and the next. And this ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Kyudo Blog #1 - The First Year

I've been practicing Kyudo for over a year now. Started in early April of last year officially. This November I'm hoping to attempt for sho-dan. And, I wanted to take some time to reflect on a few things: Why I started and why I continued. General lessons learned. Current progress and goals. As to why I started, I can't say that there is a single, clear answer. I was thinking about joining "something" and I had been somewhat intent on it being some Japanese Martial Art. Aikido was the only thing I had taken which I had remembered enjoying when I was young. I discovered Kyudo through the anime Tsurune , but I had already attempted contacting and joining the dojo in the past and that show was no longer front and centre. Then, I saw that they were sponsoring a local event which made me curious. I checked their Facebook page and they were having intro sessions later in the year. I signed up. Attended. Joined the beginners program. Completed it. Applied to join the reg...
Post a Comment
Read more