Skip to main content

Is New Brunswick's Gender Pronoun thing Controversial?

For reference I'm talking about this.

I want to keep this short. I don't affiliate with any particular party, though I do generally find myself against most Conservative party policies. As such, I find this particular topic slightly refreshing, while also annoying. 

Annoying because the Notwithstanding Clause was invoked yet again and because I don't believe it is actually needed here.

Refreshing because, on some level at least, I find myself in agreement. In fact, my primary issues of the aforementioned clause being abused again is really just that anyone felt this law was needed. 

To me, the response here is a knee-jerk reaction. It feels like rights are being stripped away and that a vulnerable portion of society is being targeted. On this matter however, I don't feel that is accurate. And maybe I'm wrong about that. Here is my thinking anyway.

The only reason I can think of to allow a child to change their own personal pronouns/gender preference at school is because their parents don't agree and/or won't assist or perhaps because they simply do not want their parents to know. And this is where it feels like a violation of rights.

While I certainly don't think it makes a ton of sense for a parent or guardian to ignore their child's wishes on this topic, allowing the child to take this matter into their own hands would not resolve the root issue; issues at home. Allowing the child to go behind the parents back or supersede them on this is likely to just make matters worse.

Frankly, I'm unsure why gender and pronouns would even be something a school would require a formal process for in the first place. I doubt that the teachers are able to enforce how the students address each other and I would wager that whether or not the teacher is supportive would be more circumstantial as well. IE - Regardless of what they register as, the teacher is likely to either respect the students wishes or not based solely on their own moral compass.

It is a cop out, but the parents and guardians are responsible for the child. This at least makes record keeping a little cleaner. If the child has the same name but a different gender on their school transcripts because the parent and child disagree, that could create additional conflicts in the future.

I think schools should recommend things like counseling if a child disagrees with their parents. Or if the rift between them has become abusive, involve law enforcement perhaps.

And I could be swayed, but at present, I don't believe there is any issue with leaving this control in the hands of the child's guardian.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Kyudo Blog #2 - Shinsa Prep

So, we're well past my first year. I decided to take the video shinsa for shodan at the end of the year. We also, have a new cohort joining the dojo. Things are getting interesting. This journey has not been at all what I expected. First, I had expected Kyudo to be both more and less introspective. Our dojo focuses more on Taihai, or the ceremonial/performance aspect of the art. And that comes with a lot of concern for harmony and beauty as a group. Making movements up to shai (firing line) in unison as much as possible.  At the same time the focus on the self is infinitely more than I could have anticipated as well. Posture, breathing, form and movements. Everything seems to have a right way of doing it. And none of those "right ways" come naturally. Beyond that there is also etiquette. Even things you might not associate with the practice itself are a part it. And all of these things then also need to be in harmony with everything else. Needless to say, I have a long wa...
Post a Comment
Read more

WoT Getting Picked Up By Another Network?

A lot of people are hoping that, since the cancellation, WoT will be picked up by another network. I don't think it will happen. I didn't mind the show and while I have some beef with it, even the quality of the show isn't the reason I don't believe it will be picked up again. This could have been the best received series of all time and no one would touch it now. Why? Because it is an unknown factor now. Basically, WoT is a show based on an existing IP with an existing fanbase. What was completed of the existing TV Series drifted so far from the books that it alienated that fanbase. This is a problem because there is no built-in audience for what comes next. The book fans have no reason to come along because the storyline from the books is no longer recoverable. And, even the TV show fans aren't a guarantee. In fact, they are especially not guaranteed here. Another unique factor here is that WoT was on Prime Video. This is a streaming service many people simply get...
Post a Comment
Read more

Alberta's Potential CPP Exit

I'll start with "bad idea" and "won't go as planned". What makes the Alberta plan so enticing is also why it will fail. Basically, a study concluded that Alberta could be entitled to as much as 53% of the funds assets. And IF that were paid out, then Alberta would be able to start it's own pension fund and pay out more for less. The problem is that they won't get that much, and they aren't realistically entitled to that much. To frame the problem better, under the most loose and beneficial interpretation, the same company ended up at a number which was 118% of the funds assets. That's right, the wording of the act is so flawed that it can create interpretations of it such that Alberta could be construed as being owed more funds than the pool has. Clearly. CLEARLY that is insane. Alberta's relative share of the contributions is 18% and their population is about 16% of the people's involved. But, if they only take 16-18% it is NOT a bet...
Post a Comment
Read more